Understanding the new DLC PPF efficacy (umols/j) standard and how it is measured

DLC has set standards accepted by US utility companies and their outside regulators to create a level playing field for how lighting products are measured in terms of energy use and efficiency of light production.


Understanding the new DLC PPF efficacy (umols/j) standard and how it is measured

Let's dive in to the new DLC 1.9 umols/j efficacy standard, how it is measured and how it's applied to horticultural grow lights. It's a technical topic but deserves attention because it will set some important baselines not only for figuring out utility energy rebates but will also fix some misleading information about lighting fixtures for grow.

Image result for Design Lights Consortium

Photo credit: DLC 

Who is DLC? Design Lights Consortium describes themselves like this: "The DLC® is a non-profit organization whose mission is to drive efficient lighting by defining quality, facilitating thought leadership, and delivering tools and resources to the lighting market through open dialogue and collaboration"  

DLC plays an important role between local energy utilities, energy conservation rebate programs managed by every utility and the regulators who oversee how rebates are measured and paid to the end-user grower. As a quick side note, every utility collects a fraction of the total amount of power they bill their consumers and sets it aside for energy conservation grants. This means that every utility in the country has a budget for rebates. They may or may not allow rebates for cannabis, but they all provide rebates for making energy efficient choices when building a facility that consumes power. Each utility has a team of engineers who manage these programs.  

DLC has set standards accepted by US utility companies and their outside regulators to create a level playing field for how lighting products are measured in terms of energy use and efficiency of light production. This allows utilities to make fact based decisions about how much energy light fixtures consume compared to one another. Basically it saves them a lot of time having to justify their own comparisons. They can choose to rely on DLC data which makes it much easier and therefore faster to calculate rebates based on energy saved.

It will take some time for DLC to process the long list of lights being marketed for grow. Until then utilities rely on their own rationale for calculating rebates, or for not allowing rebates for cannabis growing. Each utility makes their own choices based on policy.

Lighting manufacturers submit each individual light fixture along with a specific set of independent certified testing lab reports directly to DLC (along with a fee) to qualify under DLC's new standards. DLC then sifts through the data to ensure all the required standards are achieved. The light is then placed on an approved list. This list will be all new and focused entirely on any light sold for use in horticulture being submitted for an energy rebate. 

If you don't intend to ask for a rebate the DLC list isn't that important except that there is some real value in having a third party provide independent measurements of light fixture efficiency as compared to one another since claims by each manufacturer can sometimes be confusing or worse, misleading.

DLC, through a long interactive comment process, chose an efficacy (fixture efficiency) standard of 1.9 umols/j, plus or minus 5%. What this means is that any lamp which passes independent third party lab testing of 1.805 umols/j can qualify for DLC approval (subject to other standards as well).

Umols/j is the amount of photosynthetic energy the light produces divided by the amount of input wattage the lamp draws from the wall. That measurement is PPF/W. This is where the new list provides some real value. Lamp wattage, especially LED wattage, is only determined by the power drawn by the lamp. It is never determined by multiplying the total wattage capacity of the diodes. There are a growing number of LED products, particularly low cost on-line retail units being deceptively advertised as higher wattage than what is drawn from the wall. Just because a diode has a 1 watt capacity does not mean it is being supplied 1 watt of power. For the purposes of DLC standards and energy conservation there is only one way to measure wattage and that is the fixture watts consumed. Using the DLC standard will improve product comparisons which will help the consumer to make more informed choices.

So what is PPF? PPF or photosynthetic photon flux is the amount of energy being created by the light which falls within the spectrum which plants "see" through photosynthesis. This spectrum is defined as the total amount of energy between 400nm and 700nm. Spectrum graphs show the curve created by the wavelengths of light emitted in 1nm increments between 350-850nm. So from a photosynthetic energy standpoint PPF is just a portion of the total output. 

Image result for spectrum graph 4000k led

Photo credit: Cree LED

What about PAR (photosynthetic active radiation) as a measurement standard? PAR is a useful measurement of total photosynthetic light intensity being placed on the canopy. However as the industry matures PPF will become a more important comparison measurement than PAR because it includes spectrum and not just total photosynthetic light production. Once a decision is made on which light will be used in a grow, PAR is the correct measurement of total light intensity on canopy based on how far away the lamp is mounted. 

PAR, as it relates to readings from a handheld PAR meter for example is different from PPF because it takes into account distance from the light source. PAR is the same 400-700nm measurement of total energy but because it varies by distance it cannot be the reference standard. PAR is important in terms of handheld measurement devices in a grow, but it does not directly translate to total PPF.

This can be confusing because PPFD (D meaning distance from the light source) is the same as the amount of total PAR shown on a meter. So a PAR meter displays PPFD. It is not however able to measure PPF itself. It can be confusing but the issue comes from the fact that photosynthetic light is not the same thing as visible light. So translations in the math have to be applied to calculate photosynthetic light created.  

This is where it gets interesting. There is no testing device that measures PPF specifically. Instead, the light fixture is placed in an "integrating sphere" which is a device that measures the total amount of "radiant flux" being emitted by the light.

Image result for integrating sphere photo

Photo credit: LED Magazine 

Here is an important point: the integrating sphere does not measure light at a specific distance. Flux does not vary. Each light creates a specific total amount of flux. No less and no more. So we are able to rely on a measurement standard.

We all know that PAR or PPFD changes over distance. Measuring light with a PAR meter changes as the meter is moved further from the light source. 

Integrating spheres don't work that way. Every light measurement is specific and comparable to the next lamp being measured in total flux output.

Because an integrating sphere can't measure PPF directly, a formula must be used. First, all the light being created outside of 400-700nm is removed from the calculation (all the UV and all the infrared). Then a math formula is applied to each wavelength to convert radiant flux to photosynthetic photon flux. This is how total PPF is determined in the lab. There is no handheld instrument which will display PPF. It can only be measured by converting flux measured in an integrating sphere to PPF.

During the DLC standard setting process there was a lot of debate about removing energy below 400nm (ultraviolet UV radiation) and above 700nm (infrared - mostly heat - radiation). The rationale DLC chose was that these wavelengths fall outside of photosynthesis in plants. However an argument can be made the UV impacts marijuana growing and may create different terpene production. Also that infrared energy, which is created in abundance by HPS lights as mostly heat energy, also impacts the plants both in terms of heat absorption but also the overall indoor grow climate. In the end DLC considered the arguments and chose 400-700nm PPF as the standard.

The good news is we have a standard now for our evolving industry and in the coming months and years as more and more lights are submitted to DLC for approval, we'll have a better reference of comparison between lamps. Utilities also benefit because rebates are better regulated which removes a layer of uncertainty in offering energy incentives for grow lighting. 

Standards are never perfect. They always evolve from compromise and regulations feel increasingly tedious but DLC's new requirements will be a benefit to the cannabis industry long term. 

Premium Quality For Growing

More Products

Sold out -6% sale
Trolmaster HCS-2 Hydro-X Pro Control System
Trolmaster HCS-2 Hydro-X Pro Control System $ 2,374.00 $ 2,499.00
  10.1' Touchscreen Fully Customizable  Free Smart Phone App plus Web-base control system TrolMaster revolutionized environmental controller technology when it introduced the Hydro-X. The Hydro-X Pro continues the revolution with a 10’ touch-screen and a web-based software. The Hydro-X Pro is backwards compatible with all current Hydro-X control / device modules. It also provides greater flexibility and allows any plug-in module to be addressed to be whatever the user wants. The user can also set up each plug-in module to have multiple “conditions” that will activate the module, allowing for almost unlimited control options. The Hydro-x Pro is designed to be a single room controller for reliability and ease-of-use. The Hydro-X Pro expands the capability of the original Hydro-X by allowing up to 50 sensors and up to 50 separate control modules to be connected to a single Hydro-X Pro. Multiple sub-zones can be created within the single grow space by linking a specific sensor, to a specific control function(s).The new 4-in-1 sensor comes with a LCD screen which provide the ease of onside monitoring. Customized programming allows almost limitless degree of control. Each of the variables (Temperature, Humidity, CO2, Light) can be controlled independently, meaning a customized ramp-up / ramp-down can be used to closely simulate natural outdoor conditions, or simply allow complete customization of the environment. Displayed on an easy-to-read and construct “graph” it allows the user to have 100% control of their environment. Another powerful feature of the Hydro-X Pro is the built-in calendar and calendar presets that allows the user to schedule an entire crop’s “recipe” within the Hydro-X Pro. All settings including Lighting, Temperature, Humidity, CO2, and Timers can be specified by the user as they “build” their multi-week crop schedules. Reminders can also be programmed to ensure critical tasks are not forgotten. The TrolMaster APP will also allow for notifications with separate day/night limits to be received by the user. The web-based software provides easy access and more advanced remote control. Onboard data acquisition and the ability to store and share setting between multiple devices, means that user-defined programs & settings can be saved and loaded into multiple Hydro-X Pro units with ease. A personalized screensaver page can be uploaded through a USB port. The same upgradeable feature like Hydro-X gives you the ability for life-time improvements. Included: 1x HCS-2 Controller 1x MBS-Pro Sensor 1x Mounting Plate 1x RJ12 Cable Set
-1% sale
TrolMaster Hydro X Plus HCS-3 Grow Room Controller
TrolMaster Hydro X Plus HCS-3 Grow Room Controller $ 1,195.00 $ 1,199.00
The Hydro X Plus / HCS-3 system is a professional-grade single-zone environmental control system that can control your entire grow space. It has an 800x480 7” LED display monitor and can control an unlimited number of lights, 8 temperature devices, 8 humidity devices, 4 CO2 devices, and 12 programmable timer devices (up to 50 schedules can be created). With incredible flexibility and the expanded product capacity, anyone can now easily customize their own grow room control system for maximum yields. Having multiple control modules also provides the option for the user to create multiple "stages" of growth. By staggering the start times of each stage, the user can minimize the amount of time that plants spend in vegetative growth and focus on the flowering phase. Having multiple control modules also provides the option for the user to create multiple "stages" of temperature and humidity control, which will provide a more stable environment. The HCS-3 system comes with an MBS-PRO 4-in-1 sensor to measure temperature, humidity, CO2 ppm, and the presence of light. Lighting control has never been easier or more capable. The optional MBS-PAR light sensor can be added to the system. It will automatically adjust light intensity to precisely provide the exact amount of illumination for optimum plant growth. The Hydro-X Plus has been can also track your DLI levels. Having 2 separate lighting control channels allows the user to create multiple lighting layouts (and dimming sequences) based on their individual preferences. Besides controlling your room, if a problem is detected by the HCS-3, a warning message (notification) will be sent to your smartphone. Up to 10 smoke detectors and 10 water leak-detectors can be connected to the HCS-3 which will alert you if there are any fire or water leaks. The HCS-3 also offers multiple advanced functions to control your entire grow room or greenhouse such as Sunrise / Sunset simulation, DLI control, overheat protection, Spectrum & Group lighting control, and more.  
Sold out -6% sale
Trolmaster MBS-PAR Quantum Sensor for Hydro-X Pro
Trolmaster MBS-PAR Hydro-X Full Spectrum Quantum Sensor $ 417.95 $ 442.00
The Full Spectrum Quantum Sensor (MBS-PAR) provides accurate and cost-effective measurement of photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) from all light sources used to grow plants. The full-spectrum quantum sensor has a spectral range of 389 to 692 nm ± 5 nm. The improved spectral response increases the accuracy of LED measurements. 
Sold out -6% sale
Trolmaster MBS-Pro Quantum Sensor for Hydro-X Pro
Hydro X SuperstoreTrolmaster MBS-PRO Hydro-X Temp/Humid/CO2/Light 4-in-1 Sensor for Hydro-X Pro $ 377.95 $ 399.00
The MBS-PRO 4-in-1 sensor combines a precision air temperature, humidity, CO2 (PPM) sensor and photocell to create the perfect all-in-one environmental sensor. It is designed for Hydro-X Pro system only.  Assembled using a new water-resistant plastic injected enclosure, the MBS-PRO can be placed in multiple locations throughout the growing area to provide spot measurements from multiple sensors (Up to 50 sensors can be connected to the Hydro-X Pro) The sensors can then be used together (averaged) or separately in order to control a specific section of the grow area by assigning a sensor to a specific control device. The MBS-PRO features a built-in LCD display to show the current conditions of that sensor which provide the ease of onsite monitoring. It also features a new “push-lock” connection to make installation easy.Please Note: The MBS-Pro requires the SPH-1 for supplemental power. "Sensors should remain dry and clean to prevent premature failure. Do not spray foreign substances or allow water / condensate on the sensors"  
-9% sale
TrolMaster HCS-1 Controller w/3-in-1 Sensor Bundle
TrolMaster HCS-1 Controller w/3-in-1 Sensor Bundle $ 299.95 $ 329.00
If you're looking for a complete, professional-grade environmental control system, the TrolMaster Hydro-X is the perfect solution. This modular system is easy to install and expand, and can be fully customized to your needs. With the free TrolMaster App, you can access all system settings and alerts from anywhere, anytime. The Hydro-X system is compatible with most grow lights brands, HVAC systems, mini-split air conditioners, commercial dehumidifiers and humidifiers, as well as CO2 generators or regulators. So whether you're looking to maintain optimal growing conditions in your indoor garden or keep your home comfortable all year round, the Hydro-X system has you covered. Includes the TrolMaster 3 in 1 sensor bundle and RJ16 cables. A turn-key environmental sensor system to tune up your gardens success.  Looking for a trusted high volume TrolMaster Official Distributor in North America? Look no further than Forever Green Indoors! We're the leading provider of quality TrolMaster products and accessories, and we're here to help you keep your indoor spaces looking their best.We've got everything you need to keep your plants healthy and green, from TrolMaster controllers and sensors to PAR meters and EC sensors. And we're always happy to offer advice and assistance to make sure you get the most out of your TrolMaster products.So if you're looking for top-quality TrolMaster products and accessories, plus expert advice and support, come to Forever Green Indoors - we're your one
-5% sale
Trolmaster MBS-S8 Hydro-X CO2 Sensor - Accessory for HCS-1 Controller
Trolmaster MBS-S8 Hydro-X CO2 Sensor - Accessory for HCS-1 Controller $ 210.90 $ 222.00
 Description The optional CO2 Sensor (MBS-S8) measures the CO2 PPM within the growing area. Using the MBS-S8 allows the users to connect and control their supplemental CO2 system using the Hydro-X. *Used in combination with one or more DSC-1 CO2 device modules.
-5% sale
Trolmaster  4RS-1 4 Outlet Expander Station
Trolmaster 4RS-1 4 Outlet Expander Station $ 137.75 $ 145.00
The 4RS-1 is a universal 4-outlet power expansion module. It can be used with any of TrolMaster’s “plug-in” style device modules to expand the number of devices that can be controlled by the Hydro-x. A single 120-240 volt “trigger” cable on the 4RS-1 connects to your device / control module. When the device module is activated by the Hydro-x, the 4RS-1 trigger cable will turn on each of the 4 receptacles on the 4RS-1 with a 3 second time delay between each outlet being activated. That minimizes high start-up (inrush current) and allows up to 4 devices to be safely controlled. The 4RS-1 must be installed with a 120/240 volt power circuit (up to 50-amps @ 240vac). Three wire terminals inside the unit accept up to #6 AWG wire making connections to the power source easy.
5% sale
TrolMaster TSH-1 Temperature / Humidity Station
TrolMaster TSH-1 Temperature / Humidity Station $ 122.50 $ 116.38
  The Trolmaster TSH-1 Temperature / Humidity Station is a 0-10 volt analog output control station that works with the HCS-1 and HCS-2 controllers. The TSH-1 can be configured to control either a temperature or a humidity device that requires a variable 0-10 volt input signal. The TSH-1 is capable of controlling variable speed fans, vents or any other device that accepts a 0-10 volt input. It features separate day and night “idle” speed settings built-into the TSH-1 as well as separate Day / Night setpoints accessed through the HCS controller.





(Orders before 11am pst)